Part 2: Getting Past Framework Overload
I’m still pondering Seth Godin’s point that creating the conditions for learning, resilience, and commitment is the boss’s job. (See my earlier pondering here.) I’m intrigued by this triad as core organizational capacities, and by how an organization could ever make sense of three different concepts at once. Any one of them is a big lift if it wasn’t designed into the organization from the start.
I started with learning and resilience. (I’m saving commitment for another day. It’s often juxtaposed against compliance, which makes me think it matters a lot as we try to transform schools from bureaucracies into learning organizations.)
And then I ran smack into framework overload.
It’s so hard to compare frameworks, let alone integrate them. That was the hard work Sydney Schaef and I did in Wired for Brilliance (coming early 2027): gather the research on how we learn, connect it, and boil it down into the ABCs of Learning (agency, belonging, and competence).
Three questions hiding in one word
Reading the resilience research, I kept bouncing off walls. Different structures, packed sub-levels, and different vocabulary. Yep, cognitive overload big time. Then it clicked that when Godin, or any of us, talks about learning or resilience in an organization, we might be asking three different questions:
- What does the person bring? Does this employee (or manager, or board member) know how to learn and adapt? Do they have the emotional skills to bounce back or keep going when the going gets hard? For employees, the question becomes: how do I get better at learning, or at being resilient?
- What conditions enable it? What in the workplace (schools included) cultivates those capacities? For learning, Sydney and I focus on the ABCs. The culture, formal and informal, shapes employees in all kinds of ways, including how resilient they are when the organization is under stress.
- What are the qualities of the organization itself? What makes it a learning organization or a resilient one?
These overlap, of course. (Think Venn diagram.) But to make sense of any framework, I had to figure out which question it was answering. Sydney and I spend our days on questions one and two. I found myself drawn to question three, partly because I’d never thought about a resilient organization before, and curiosity led the way.
What I found
So if I’m a boss, how do I create a learning organization that is also a resilient organization? Can I blend these two frameworks together at the organizational level?
First insight. They are entirely different fields. The learning organization field tends to focus on employee capacity. Peter Senge’s version (The Fifth Discipline is my beloved go-to) is mostly about the capacities of the people: systems thinking, personal mastery, mental models, shared vision, and team learning.
So Godin’s call to see this as the boss’s job, not just the employees, makes sense. Are you creating the conditions for your people to develop and tap into these “disciplines”? Does the organization have the processes that give employees what they need? (I can’t help but think about schools that want to innovate but haven’t figured out how to give teachers opportunity for professional learning communities (PLCs). It’s a non-negotiable for creating teacher efficacy, Hattie’s top practice that leads to learning.)
Organizational resilience is a whole field of its own. Pick your initials and you can find a framework: ICOR, WEF, and BCI, to name a few. Best I understand, it’s the ability of an organization to respond to change and disruption, big and small, so that it survives and thrives. Learning is a big piece of that. But there’s more to it.
Here’s the breakthrough, with help from my friend Claude. (I’m interpreting here, so tell me if you know this field better.) Learning is a core ingredient of resilience because it builds adaptability, but it’s not the whole enchilada. Resilience also requires robustness: the internal systems and capacities that hold when stress hits, like plans, redundancy, and risk management. Senge feeds adaptability heavily and robustness hardly at all. And an organization can be robust without learning much. Good luck when the next disruption swings by and you can’t engage your employees in creating new processes, procedures, and systems.
(Beware: just like education, words take on all kinds of meanings. In the field of organizational resilience, robustness has its own meaning but is sometimes used interchangeably with resilience.Thank you AI for guiding me rather than letting me wander through the field in utter confusion.)
Overcoming framework overload
If a company needs learning, resilience, and commitment, the tempting move is three frameworks, three initiatives, and probably three committees. I’ve got plenty of memories of inter-department implosion from my nonprofit management days of trying to heal wounded organizations. And I don’t know how districts and schools do it when they work with different TA providers (technical assistance, for those who speak fewer acronyms). That’s exactly where frameworks collide.
I’ve always wondered whether programs that last tend to be integrated. Take YouthBuild and Big Picture Learning. They’ve woven youth development, learning sciences, and workforce development into one approach. Same core beliefs, very different models. Point to almost any practice in them and it makes sense for several reasons at once: for the young people served, for the staff, and for the organization. A practice isn’t there for one framework. It’s doing triple duty.
Building 21 is the same. The learning sciences and youth development sit at the very core of absolutely everything they do.
Which brings me back to my own wobbling through these frameworks. How can organizations focus on learning, resilience, and commitment (or whatever you choose as your core beliefs about a strong organization, if you don’t like Godin’s) without being buried in frameworks?
We usually start with the frameworks producing charts outlining similarities and differences. What if we start with current practices instead. That’s , what I did whenever I took on leading a change effort in a nonprofit. I’d ask why. I asked why all day long. It irritated staff until they understood I was trying to learn their perspectives, experiences, and knowledge. Once they realized I wasn’t out to get them, they became “why birds” themselves. Our meetings were full of chirping whys.
Try it yourself. Pick one practice in your organization and ask why you do it the way you do. Does it make sense for the people you serve, for the employees, and for the organization? Or are you doing it because state or federal reporting demands it? If you can give three, you’ve found something sturdy. If you can only give one reason, it’s probably an add-on, and add-ons are the first thing to go when budgets tighten or leaders change. Notice that’s the bouncing back and forth through the three questions again, just inside a practice instead of a framework. Integration isn’t a fourth framework. It’s a way of choosing practices.
I suspect the ABCs of Learning do triple duty, since agency, belonging, and competence showing up in learning, in resilience, and in commitment. That’s my hunch, not a finding. Exploring it is for another day.
Over to you
- Think of one practice at your workplace (a weekly meeting, an onboarding routine, a debrief) that serves more than one purpose. What are all the reasons it works?
- Of the three questions (the person, the conditions, the organization), which one gets the most attention where you work? Which gets the least?
- If you had to drop two of your current initiatives, which would you keep because they do the most jobs at once?